Comment on "Elucidating the mechanism of nucleation near the gas-liquid spinodal".

We have constructed a multidimensional free energy surface of nucleation of the liquid phase from the parent supercooled and supersaturated vapor phase near the gas-liquid spinodal. In particular, we remove the Becker-Doring constraint of having only one growing cluster in the system. Close to the spinodal, the free energy, as a function of the size of the largest cluster, develops surprisingly a minimum at a subcritical cluster size. It is this minimum at intermediate size that is found to be responsible for the barrier towards further growth of the nucleus at large supersaturation. An alternative free energy pathway involving the participation of many subcritical clusters is found near the spinodal where the growth of the nucleus is promoted by a coalescence mechanism. The growth of the stable phase becomes collective and spatially diffuse, and the significance of a "critical nucleus" is lost for deeper quenches.